Adam Bennett: Okay, here's a fact that many owners don't think about. One marketing manager at a small Southeastern shop costs about sixty-five hundred dollars a month. That's wages only: no benefits, no software, no ad budget. And that's just one person. So the real question isn't hire or outsource. It's what do you need done, and who can do it? Welcome to Pest Control Marketing That Actually Works, the podcast for pest control operators who want real growth, not empty promises. I'm Adam Bennett.
Elisabeth Pallante: And I'm Elisabeth Pallante. We're from Cube Creative Design, and for over twenty years we've helped pest control companies stop wasting money and start growing.
Adam Bennett: Today's episode: building an internal marketing team versus outsourcing. We promised this one way back in Episode 43. And one thing up front: we're an agency, so we sell the outsource side of this question. Hold us to that. We'll give you the honest case for hiring as well. Here's what we're answering today.
Elisabeth Pallante: First, what does one marketing hire really cost next to an agency plan? Second, what does each side actually do, and do well? Third, for a two to fifteen truck company, do you hire first, outsource first, or split it?
Adam Bennett: Let's start with the number most owners guess wrong, and that's the manager number. For a small pest company in the Southeast, a marketing manager runs about $78,000 a year. That's roughly $6,500 a month. That's our estimate for shops this size, not a national figure. The national median for the job is much higher.
Elisabeth Pallante: And that's wages only, with no benefits, taxes, software, recruiting, or ad budget. We can't price recruiting or software for you, so we won't guess. That's going to depend. Benefits, though, the same Bureau tracks. In June 2026, at private businesses with under 50 workers, benefits were about a quarter of what employers spent per hour worked.
Adam Bennett: Two caveats on that. The benefits share covers all jobs, not just marketers. And the pay figure is our estimate for a small shop in the Southeast, so your town could be higher or lower. Either way, a hire costs more than the wage.
Elisabeth Pallante: I think a lot of owners guess low here. They picture somebody who posts on Facebook, and they think of that kind of pay. And not every shop needs a manager. For the other roles, I'll use the Bureau of Labor Statistics national medians, so they run a bit high for a small Southeastern shop. A writer is almost $77,000 a year. A graphic designer, about $63,000 a year. And a web developer or digital designer, almost a hundred thousand.
Adam Bennett: So if you hire all four, manager included, you're looking at just over $317,000 a year. That's about $26,500 a month before benefits. Nobody with six trucks is doing that, and I'd be surprised if a 15-truck shop needs it either. That's a team for a much bigger company.
Elisabeth Pallante: Here's our side, from our pricing page, and we'll say it again: we're an agency, and this is what we sell. Foundation is $1,500 a month. Growth is $2,400 a month. Dominance is $4,000 a month. Paid for the year, that's $16,200, $25,920, and $43,200. Your Google Ads budget is on top of that.
Adam Bennett: Here's the ratio people will quote. At the annual price, one marketing manager at a small Southeastern shop costs about 1.8 times our top plan and almost five times our Foundation plan. That comparison makes us look great, and it isn't fair, because it's not apples to apples.
Elisabeth Pallante: A plan is a package of set work. A hire is yours all day. They answer the phone, take a photo at the truck, and do things no plan is going to cover. Compare only price tags and the agency wins every time, and that's the trap. Count what you need done, not just what it costs.
Adam Bennett: Here's the other honest part. Our plans say they're ideal for 10 to 25 technicians, 15 to 40, and 40 plus. So a shop with 2 to 6 trucks sits below every plan we sell. At that size, a full-time manager isn't the obvious answer, and neither is a full plan from us.
Elisabeth Pallante: And both paths are commitments. Our plans are a one-year agreement that renews, and you can leave with thirty days' notice before the renewal. A hire means recruiting and training, and if it doesn't work out, you start over from the beginning. Neither one is free to walk away from.
Adam Bennett: A marketing hire costs more than you think and does more than a plan does. Both are true.
Elisabeth Pallante: Let me make the case for hiring, because it gets shortchanged. Someone in the building knows the trucks, the techs, and the customers by name. They hear the phones, and your best content ideas come from the phone: the questions you hear, what people worry about. An agency hears that secondhand, if at all.
Adam Bennett: And then there's the field work. Job photos, a tech on camera for thirty seconds, the review ask. Way back in Episode 16, we said technicians who ask for reviews in person get three to four times more reviews. We can coach that and write the words for it, but we can't stand in the driveway with the customer.
Elisabeth Pallante: And some jobs are half marketing, half operations: answering leads, scheduling, follow-up calls, and updating the Google Business Profile between jobs. In Episode 5, we said that upkeep runs about 10 minutes a week. That's an in-house job. An agency plan doesn't flex into your front office.
Adam Bennett: Okay, now the case for outside help. One hire is one skill set. The person who writes well may not know Google Ads. The person who runs ads may not be able to fix your website. And the person who fixes the website may have no idea how to write. You pay the full wage for someone who may be great at one thing and okay at the rest. An agency gives you several skills for one price.
Elisabeth Pallante: Several specialties, right?
Adam Bennett: Absolutely.
Elisabeth Pallante: The second case for outside help is coverage. If your one marketer is sick, on vacation, or quits, the work comes to a grinding halt. And stopped marketing costs money. In Episode 22, we said pausing ads for three months can raise your cost per lead 30 to 50% when you restart. A gap doesn't just pause things. It can set you back.
Adam Bennett: Now, looking at our own numbers really carefully. Based on how much time we usually spend on a client, it can be anywhere between eight and fifteen hours a month.
Elisabeth Pallante: And our logs showed one more thing. In a given month, one person did most of the work on each pest client. Picture one person who knows your account, and sometimes a second or third when it needs something they don't do. Don't picture five people in your account every day. That's not how it works in our logs.
Adam Bennett: What the logs can't show is how the time splits between content, web, and ads, so we won't guess. In-house wins on knowing the business: the phones, the field, the front office. Outside help wins on a range of skills, and on not stopping when one person is out.
Elisabeth Pallante: In-house knows your business, and an agency knows marketing. The question is which gap hurts you more.
Adam Bennett: So how do you decide whether to hire or outsource? We call it the desk test. Three desks, each one a yes or no question.
Elisabeth Pallante: First, a full desk. Is there a full week of marketing work every week, all year, not just in the spring? If the work fits in a few hours a week, a full-time hire fills the rest with something else, usually the phones.
Adam Bennett: Second, your desk. Does the work need to happen in your building? Phones, photos, review asks, front-office follow-up. If most of it does, that points to a hire.
Elisabeth Pallante: Third, the boss's desk. Is there someone who can manage a marketer, set the goals, and judge the work? If the honest answer is nobody, your new hire is on their own, and that's not their fault. Nobody does good work when nobody's checking in.
Adam Bennett: Scoring: three yes answers, hire first. One or none, outsource first. Two, and you split it. One warning: answer for your busiest month, not your slowest. If you say "sure, I'll manage them," and then you're on a truck all day in May, you failed the third desk.
Elisabeth Pallante: And here's where we disagree a bit. Take a six-truck shop with a few thousand a month to spend. I say hire first: somebody who picks up the phone, chases reviews, and knows the customers. Outside help for the skilled pieces can come later, once you know what's missing. The phone is where a small shop wins or loses the job the most, and I want to see that covered by someone I can see.
Adam Bennett: I'd go the other way. I'd say outsource first, and I'm not just saying that because we're an agency, though we do sell the outsource-first answer, so weigh that. Most small shops fail the first desk, and the owner can't judge a marketer's work yet. One person at about sixty-five hundred bucks a month in wages, or even a lower-paid generalist, is a big bet on one person's skills. If the fit is wrong, you've lost time you can't get back.
Elisabeth Pallante: That does happen, and I've seen it. And I'll grant the limit on my side: if nobody in the building can manage a marketer, hiring first fails the third desk, and that hire is on their own. They need some oversight, some check that they're on the right path, even if they're a great worker. But a person in the building builds daily habits like the review ask and the photo after the job. You can't order that with any plan.
Adam Bennett: Here's the limit on my side. If you're a two to six truck shop, you sit below every plan we sell, so the right first step for you may not be us. Where outsourcing first fits, a partner shows you what good looks like, and then you can hire for the gap you see.
Elisabeth Pallante: And the gap you see first is usually the phone and the field. So neither of us wins this one. It depends on how many of the three desks you can honestly say yes to.
Adam Bennett: Here's where we do agree. Whoever does the work, every task gets a name and a day. In Episode 41, we gave you the three-beat calendar: weekly, monthly, and quarterly. It works the same in-house or outsourced.
Elisabeth Pallante: Hire for the desk you have, not the one you wish you had. With this, most of you will land in the middle. Option one is the office person with marketing hours. Someone already on your team owns the weekly beat: Google Business Profile, review asks, photos. Outside help handles the content, the website, and the ads.
Adam Bennett: I'd look at that one first, because that person already knows the customers. Option two is a part-time or junior hire for the in-building work, plus a specialist for the skilled work. That costs less than a manager and it's still yours, but it needs somebody who can manage them, because the third desk doesn't go away.
Elisabeth Pallante: Option three is a freelancer for one job, like a website rebuild or a batch of content. That's fine for a project. It breaks when you need someone every month, because then you're the project manager checking the work.
Adam Bennett: Option four is outsource now, plan to hire later. Let the partner build the system and the habits, then bring the in-building work in-house as you grow. Before you sign, ask an agency how it handles that handoff, and that includes us.
Elisabeth Pallante: Each setup breaks its own way. A hire goes wrong when they're alone, nobody manages them, and they get pulled onto the phones every spring. An agency goes wrong when nobody inside sends photos or says what the phones are hearing. We really need that feedback. A split goes wrong when the line isn't clear. If both sides think the other one owns the Google Business Profile, then nobody does. So write down every task and its owner, and share that list. Communicate.
Adam Bennett: And for two to six trucks, I'll say it one more time: you're below every plan listed. But that doesn't mean a marketing agency can't help you, especially with consulting. There are many other options. Start with the weekly beat in-house, owned by one named person, and buy outside help one project at a time until there's a full desk. That beat is small, about 10 minutes a week on the Google Business Profile. We talked about that way back in Episode 5. The monthly and the quarterly beats are where outside help really earns its price.
Elisabeth Pallante: Also aim for the other number we talked about in that same episode: two to five new reviews per week. That only happens if someone in your building, or the tech, is asking. So the person inside doesn't need to be a marketer. They need to be someone who shows up every week.
Adam Bennett: Here's the honest admission. Neither side works without somebody inside who cares about it. Can I say that louder for the people in the back?
Elisabeth Pallante: Most shops don't need a team or an agency. They need one person inside who owns it, and help for the rest. So here's your one thing to fix this week. Write down every marketing task that happened last month. Next to each one, write who did it and whether it had to happen in your building.
Adam Bennett: Then run the desk test. Is there a full desk of work? Does it need your desk? And is there someone at the boss's desk who can manage it? Count your yes answers, and that tells you whether to hire, outsource, or split it, before you spend a dollar on either one.
Elisabeth Pallante: If this episode was useful to you, follow the show on Apple Podcasts or Spotify. New episodes land every Tuesday.
Adam Bennett: Elisabeth, let's recap three things you can take on your next drive.
Elisabeth Pallante: First, one marketing manager at a small Southeastern shop costs about $78,000 a year, which is about $6,500 a month in wages alone. That's our estimate. An agency plan costs less, but it's a package of set work. A hire is yours all day and can do work no plan covers, like phones and front-office follow-up. Number two, run the desk test. Is there a full desk of work every week? Does it need to happen in your building? And is there someone to manage a marketer? Three yes answers, hire first. One or none, outsource first. If it's two, split it. Number three, most two-to-15-truck shops land in the middle. Put one named person inside on the weekly beat and buy help for the skilled work. Neither side works without someone inside who owns it.
Adam Bennett: If you want help putting any of this to work, visit marketingthatactuallyworks.ai for your free pest control marketing audit. We'll show you exactly what's working and what's costing you money.
Elisabeth Pallante: And if you want to see how your site looks to AI search, get your free Cube Score at thecubescore.com. While you're at it, grab our 20-point pest control marketing checklist.
Adam Bennett: If you got any value today, leave us a five-star review. It helps other pest control operators find the show. Next Tuesday: TikTok for pest control. Is it worth your time? Hannah's going to join us and tell us exactly that.
Elisabeth Pallante: Thanks for listening to Pest Control Marketing That Actually Works. We'll see you next Tuesday.