Adam Bennett: Here's what happens every time the economy gets a little shaky. The owner looks at his monthly bills, sees his ad spend, and then turns it off. It feels like saving money. Then the phone gets quiet, and the people who still call are the ones who already knew your name. That's the group we're going to talk about protecting. Welcome to Pest Control Marketing That Actually Works, the podcast for pest control operators who want real growth, not empty promises. I'm Adam Bennett.
Elisabeth Pallante: And I'm Elisabeth Pallante. We're from Cube Creative Design, and for over twenty years we've helped pest control companies stop wasting money and start growing.
Adam Bennett: In Episode 43, we said next week we'd cover what to protect when money gets tight. Then MAICON happened, and Chad took last week's episode on AI search. So this is the follow-up we promised, just one week late. Today's episode is Marketing During Economic Uncertainty, and here's what we're answering.
Elisabeth Pallante: First, what can search data actually tell a pest control owner about a tight economy, and what can it not? Second, when you have to cut, what do you protect first and cut last? And third, do you keep the ads running or move that money somewhere else?
Adam Bennett: So let's start with what our numbers do and don't say.
Elisabeth Pallante: When money gets really tight, the first marketing line most owners cut is the ads. It's the biggest number on the card, and you can turn it off today with one easy click. Nothing bad happens the first week, and that's the trap. It feels like free money.
Adam Bennett: Before we tell anybody what to cut, we owe you the limits of our own data. Our Search Console export starts in mid-September. That's about six weeks of data, one season, just the fall, with no recession in it anywhere. And no review or referral data, just organic search. So nothing we show you today proves how pest marketing behaves in a downturn. Treat it as a look at fall, not a forecast.
Elisabeth Pallante: We looked at 10 of our pest control clients, five full weeks, September 21 through October 25. We split their searches into two groups: searches that include the company's own name, and everything else. Someone typing your company name goes in one bucket, and someone typing "termite inspection near me" goes in the other.
Adam Bennett: The name searches barely moved. Every week, those companies showed up in name searches somewhere between 3,400 and 4,100 times. The other bucket bounced around a lot more, anywhere from 38,000 to 50,000 a week. The people who already know you keep looking you up at about the same rate, and everybody else comes and goes.
Elisabeth Pallante: Now the part that will look really scary on your own report. Weekly clicks went 365, then 366, then a peak of 420 the week of October 5, then 326, then 285. That last week is 32% below the peak. And these are small numbers, remember: hundreds of clicks across 10 sites, not millions.
Adam Bennett: That slide is what fall looks like in pest. Bugs slow down, calls slow down, and we can't say any of it is the economy. If your calls drop in November, pull up the same weeks from last year before you blame the economy, your marketing, or us.
Elisabeth Pallante: We did a year-over-year look as well. Only three of the 10 sites had usable data from last year for the same stretch, mid-September to late October. Clicks were basically flat, 309 this year against 315 last year, down 2%. But those sites showed up in far more searches, about 37,000 this year against about 22,700 last year, up 64%.
Adam Bennett: So more people saw them, and about the same number clicked. More visibility didn't turn into more clicks, at least not yet. Three sites is a really tiny sample, and I wouldn't build a whole plan on that.
Elisabeth Pallante: One possible reason is AI answers. When Google answers a question at the top of the page, people see your listing but don't always click. We can't prove that's what happened here. Our data doesn't separate AI answers from regular results. Treat it as a question to watch, not a finding. The steadiest thing in the data is the people who already know your name. We can see that. That's not a recession prediction. It's just who kept showing up consistently. And it's the group this whole episode is about: your base, the people who would call you anyway if you make it easy.
Adam Bennett: Six weeks of data won't predict a recession. It will tell you who keeps searching for you by name.
Elisabeth Pallante: If the base is the steady part, the next question is what you protect first. So we put it in order and called it the Last-Cut List. It has five lines. The top of the list is what you cut last, and the bottom is what you cut first.
Adam Bennett: Number one is reviews and your Google Business Profile. It's the cheapest thing you own, and it's the first thing nervous customers check. In Episode 5, we said keeping the profile current takes about ten minutes a week, with a target of two to five new reviews a week. Ten minutes is not a huge budget line.
Elisabeth Pallante: And fresh reviews count. BrightLocal's survey this year of about a thousand US adults found that 74% look for reviews from the last three months. So getting them is a tech habit, not a marketing spend. In Episode 16, we found that techs who ask for a review in person get three to four times more reviews. And that costs nothing extra when money's tight.
Adam Bennett: Number two is past customers: email, service reminders, and the renewal call. These people already said yes once, and an email is cheap. In Episode 10, we put the return at about 36 dollars for every dollar spent. In a tight year, the cheapest customer is the one you already have.
Elisabeth Pallante: Number three is being found by name. When somebody searches your company, they find a current profile, a website that works, and a phone that somebody actually answers. You can have perfect search results and a voicemail box that's full.
Adam Bennett: Absolutely. How many times have we called a client, it goes to voicemail, and the voicemail's full? That's such an easy fix.
Adam Bennett: Number four is the core ad budget, the ads that actually book jobs. Hold it steady and don't pause it. We're going to argue about what steady means in the next segment, so get ready for that, Elisabeth. Number five is what you cut first: experiments, new channels you started on a hunch, sponsorships you can't track, and thin content nobody reads.
Elisabeth Pallante: The cheap things sit on top because of the data. Across those 10 clients over five weeks, 37% of all the clicks came from searches with the company's name in them. That's more than a third. It's a big number.
Adam Bennett: But here's the catch. Google's own Search Console help pages say it leaves out rare searches to protect privacy. In our data, that hid almost half of the clicks. Of the clicks we can actually see, around 70% were name searches. So the real share sits somewhere between a third and 70%, and we can't say where.
Elisabeth Pallante: Google's tricky that way. This list is a judgment call. We didn't measure reviews or referrals in this data, so we can't prove reviews beat ads or content in a downturn. It's built on what's cheap and what's steady, not on a study.
Adam Bennett: The list protects the base first because it's cheap, not because it's the only thing that matters. If you protect the top three and starve everything else, you keep your customers and you stop getting new ones. That's the next segment.
Elisabeth Pallante: When money gets tight, protect the people who already know your name. They're the cheapest and most reliable customers you'll ever get. Now let's talk about whether to keep the ads running. Start with where we agree: don't turn the ads off. Episode 22 found that if you pause your ads for three months, your cost per lead can go up 30 to 50% when you restart. You pay to stop, and then you pay again to start. The question is what you do instead, and that's where you and I split a bit.
Adam Bennett: Here's my take. Hold the core ad budget flat. If those ads are booking jobs at a cost you can see, don't touch it, even when everything else is getting cut. A trim is one small step from a pause. You cut a little in November, it's quiet. You cut a little more in December, and soon you've paused without ever deciding to pause.
Elisabeth Pallante: This is my other take. There's no one formula that works in every market. You know your own market, your people, your base, and you can decide what's best for your business. But in my opinion, trim the ads, don't pause them, and move that money into the base: past-customer email, review asks, service reminders. A tight year is when keeping a customer is worth more than finding a new one. The steady demand in our data is people who already know the company, so spend where that demand already is. The ads are the expensive part, and a little money in the base can go a long way.
Adam Bennett: But the base doesn't bring in new customers, and the ads do. A Harvard Business Review study of almost 5,000 public companies across three recessions found that the best odds of coming out ahead went to companies that cut costs through efficiency but still outspent rivals on marketing. And cheap only works if somebody does it. The ads run whether you're busy or not. I'll add, we saw this during COVID. Companies that kept up their marketing, and even increased it, were more successful at keeping customers. Plenty of people weren't spending during COVID, but the ones who marketed got the business.
Elisabeth Pallante: For that study, it only covers public companies, not necessarily six-truck shops. But you're right that the email and review asks only happen if someone actually owns them. That's a problem we'll get to in just a moment.
Adam Bennett: Here's a weak spot in what we're saying. On the three sites with last year's data, they showed up in 64% more searches and clicks stayed flat. So if you move money into content, six weeks from now you may not see much.
Elisabeth Pallante: I agree with that. Our own content is slow, and showing up more doesn't necessarily bring more clicks right away. My case is mostly reviews, emails, and reminders. We can't say those did worse, because they weren't measured in this data. And there's a weak spot in your setup too: this data can't show how much the ads feed the name searches. Maybe a lot, maybe not much.
Adam Bennett: Absolutely. These are just base numbers. I can't prove the ads are what keeps people searching the name. If you can see cost per booked job from your ads, holding flat is easy to defend, because you know exactly what you're buying.
Elisabeth Pallante: And I can't prove the base does better with the extra money. If you can't track what the ads book, trimming and moving that money to customers you already know is the safer bet, since you know who those people are. If you have no idea what your ads book, fix that first, before you cut anything else.
Adam Bennett: So the answer depends on what you can measure. One of the big things we always work on is conversion tracking, especially if you're running Google Ads. Make sure your Google Analytics and your Google Tag Manager are set up so conversions come all the way from the ad to your booked client. That's very valuable information, so you know exactly where your money's going. You decide how much stays on based on what you can actually measure. And if you can't measure it, a lot of this is a moot point until you can.
Elisabeth Pallante: Last question. Say you made a cut. How do you know it didn't hurt?
Adam Bennett: Watch one number: how many searches include your company name each week. That's called branded search. It's in Search Console, and if it holds, your base is holding. Compare it to the same weeks last year, not last month. Last month will lie to you in November, because our own clicks slid about a third from the early October peak, and that's just fall in pest.
Elisabeth Pallante: And like we mentioned, AI has changed this over the past year. One odd thing in our data: name searches held steady, but clicks on those name searches dropped from 169 to 108 between the peak week and the last week of October. That's down about 35%. And six weeks can't tell us why. It's too short.
Adam Bennett: That's why clicks aren't the only thing you watch. Some people say clicks are a vanity metric. Watch your calls booked. Clicks can slide while booked jobs hold, and it can go the other way too.
Elisabeth Pallante: My second number is reviews per week. If you drop under two a week, the base isn't losing demand. It's losing attention, because somebody stopped asking. In Episode 41, we said owner dependency is a business-value issue. When money's tight, the owner is the first one pulled onto a truck or into the bills. Then the review asks and the emails stop, right when you really need them.
Adam Bennett: Put a name and a day next to every line on the Last-Cut List, and make it someone other than the owner, please. Then give any cut a review date about 90 days out and put it on the calendar. That's long enough to see past one slow month and short enough to undo it before spring. Otherwise a short-term cut quietly turns permanent.
Elisabeth Pallante: It happens a lot. Delegate it. That's totally delegatable. Is that a word?
Adam Bennett: Delegatable, yeah, for sure.
Elisabeth Pallante: And spring is closer than it feels. Episode 11's goal is 40 to 60% of April capacity booked by the end of February. So a cut you make in November shows up in that number.
Adam Bennett: If you don't have Google Search Console connected, or you don't track how calls book, you can't check any of this. So set that up before you cut anything. Otherwise you're just guessing, and guessing is how good owners end up cutting the cheap thing that was actually working.
Elisabeth Pallante: Who actually runs all this, an in-house person or an outside team, is next week. For now, cut what you can't measure first. Protect what people already know you for last.
Elisabeth Pallante: Here's your one thing to fix this week. Write your Last-Cut List, five lines in order: reviews and your Google profile, past customers, being found by name, your core ads, and the things you'd cut first. Put a name next to each one that is not the owner's.
Adam Bennett: And then open Google Search Console and write down how many searches included your company name last week. That is your base. If you ever have to cut, that's the number you check first. It takes ten minutes or even less, and it's the best early warning you've got.
Elisabeth Pallante: If this one was useful, follow the show on Apple Podcasts or Spotify. New episodes land every Tuesday, and you won't have to go looking.
Adam Bennett: I know where it is. I'll be here next week.
Adam Bennett: Here are three things to take on your next drive.
Elisabeth Pallante: First, be honest about the data. Six weeks of fall search data can't predict a recession. What it does show: people who already know a company keep searching its name at a steady rate, even when everything else moves around. Second, use the Last-Cut List. Protect reviews and your Google profile first, then past customers, then being found by name, then your core ads. Cut experiments and anything you can't track first. Third, don't turn the ads off. Restarting costs way more than staying on. Whether you hold them flat or trim and move the money to your existing customers depends on what you can actually measure.
Adam Bennett: If you want help putting this to work, visit marketingthatactuallyworks.ai for your free pest control marketing audit. We'll show you exactly what's working and what's costing you money.
Elisabeth Pallante: And if you want to see how your site looks to AI search, get your free Cube Score at thecubescore.com. While you're at it, grab our 20-point Pest Control Marketing Checklist.
Adam Bennett: We keep improving the Cube Score for pest control companies. We can now show AI mentions and AI searches, where you're showing up, and where your competitors are showing up. A whole lot of great information. It's a free report, and it takes about 60 seconds to run. I'd highly recommend going there.
Elisabeth Pallante: Super useful.
Adam Bennett: If you got any value today, leave us a five-star review. It helps other pest control operators find the show. Next Tuesday's episode, and this is exciting: building an internal marketing team versus outsourcing.
Elisabeth Pallante: Thanks for listening to Pest Control Marketing That Actually Works. We'll see you next Tuesday.